AI Supply Chains, IT Outages and AI Threat Actors
AI supply chains, separate IT outages and AI-powered threat actors lead the November 17 discussion on Techstrong Gang. Mike Vizard and Alan Shimel host Kate Scarcella, Chris Blask, Anne Ahola Ward and Jon Swartz. The panel examines international technology agreements, service reliability and the risks of automated intrusion tools.
Peace in Our AI Time
The United States and nine allies have signed a pact to secure AI supply chains and counter China. Meanwhile, new chip-access restrictions frame planned meetings with Xi and Putin. The agreements bring supply security and access to computing into the same diplomatic conversation.
However, businesses across the region face different pressures. Reporting examines the impact of new AI rules on Southeast Asia. In addition, protests over the Pax Silica project in the Philippines highlight local opposition. The discussion considers how allied coordination affects AI supply chains without overlooking regional economic interests.
More IT Outages
Separate disruptions have affected banking, aviation and workplace software. Reports describe widespread online outages at major U.S. banks and a United Airlines system outage that delayed hundreds of flights. Meanwhile, Workday restored service following a widespread disruption.
These incidents put operational resilience back in focus. The panel considers service dependencies, recovery testing and communication with affected customers. Each outage requires its own assessment. The reports do not establish a shared cause, and the discussion does not assume that cyberattacks caused these disruptions.
AI Threat Actors
The FBI warns that threat actors are rapidly increasing their use of AI-powered platforms. Tools that accelerate legitimate security testing can also accelerate intrusions. As a result, defenders must distinguish authorized assessments from malicious activity.
The panel also examines ARTEX, AI penetration testing and the rogue-locksmith problem. The conversation focuses on permission, access boundaries and accountability. Faster testing alone does not resolve those concerns. Clear scope and oversight remain central to the responsible use of security tools.
Together, the three segments examine safeguards at different levels: international supply agreements, resilient business services and authorized security testing. The discussion keeps those issues distinct while considering their practical consequences for enterprise technology teams.
Transcript
Hey everyone, happy Tuesday and welcome to the Techstrong gang. I love as we get closer to the holiday season. My mood's kind of, whether I'm in a festive mood or whatever, but I can't help this nagging feeling about every day it's another network down, or waiting for the other shoe to drop.
It's crazy. I'm sure we're going to find something out about this, but I don't know when. But we've got a good gang to talk about things like that today.
Let me introduce you. First of all, our usual Tuesday duo of Chris Blask and Kate Scarcella. That's not a new iPhone by Apple either, by the way.
It's Chris and Kate. Joining Chris and Kate, speaking of Apple, she usually has a word or two to say about it, but I'm glad to see her back on our show, the one and only Anne Anne Ahola Ward Ward. Anne, it's good to see you.
Good to see you too. It's been a while. I'm wondering, no Thanksgiving in the background?
Nothing we haven't decorated yet? It's subtle. Oh, it's subtle.
Subtle for Thanksgiving. Subtle. Okay.
Yeah. Don't worry, it's going to blow up for Christmas. All right.
I'm counting on it. Joining Anne, Chris, and Kate are our two, Mr. West Coast and Mr.
East Coast, Jon Swartz and Mike Vizard. Gentlemen, welcome. Good to see you.
Good to see you. Good to see you both. So, as I kind of teased in the beginning, it seems every day something is out again.
Today, nothing too important, just the US classified network, I think, is down. And I didn't read all the pages, Chris. Was it SIPRNet that's down or some other network?
I haven't kept up on it, but yes, I think it's SIPR. Yeah. All right.
Crazy. Mike, are you responsible for this? What's going on?
Are we flipping the order of things? We can do that, but we- No. I was just shooting it ...
All right. You just riff the top. What do you got first for us?
All right. So, while all that other stuff is going on, which we will come back to in a minute, the President has touched down for his meeting with the heads of the Chinese government and the Russian government. Did you say the President scored a touchdown?
No, I said his plane has touched down. Oh. Oh, I thought you were doing football.
I think that cold is affecting you here. Mm-hmm. All right.
So, the long story short here, though, is it appears that, just as he touched down, they kind of tightened what might've been a loophole that we talked about in the Nvidia case, where this company had been renting out AI chips without violating the export restrictions, technically. " John, it seems to me like the President wants to go to this meeting and do some horse trading and use AI chips as kind of the bargaining thing, and then what are we going to get in return, or what's your take on what's happening here? There's a lot to unpack with this.
There's this declaration that we mentioned. So the US and these nine allied nations created something called the San Francisco Declaration on the Secure Foundations of Enduring Prosperity. So basically, they want to establish a joint list of sensitive AI technologies and supply chains requiring heightened security.
And they do this, they launch it just ahead of the US-China talks at APEC. And I think there's something going on. What Washington is trying to do is harden their strategy that links economic security to national security.
On paper, it all looks and sounds fine, but the irony, and it's rich in irony, is that the President, whose hands have been dirtied by this whole Nvidia scandal, as well as his commerce secretary, who was on the trip by the way, Howard Lutnick, they are enmeshed in this Nvidia fiasco. And I think there's a kind of a contradiction going on here. So Washington wants to bar direct sales of high-end AI chips to China.
It's always been saying that. But the major loophole, as you mentioned, is that Chinese firms are accessing this power remotely by renting cloud capacity from overseas data centers. And to make things even more bizarre, Nvidia this morning, Tuesday, announced that its board of directors has created a new committee to oversee national security policies and compliance with US export controls, which is a little bit late right now considering what's going on.
So the thing about Trump is, when he meets with Xi Jinping, he's probably not going to address it directly. I'm not even sure how much he's going to say. But he's in a sense been totally compromised when we're making these proclamations, either by the government or by Nvidia, to address an issue that has blown up in their faces.
And the fallout is everywhere. And the black eye, I know they're making an effort to try to address this, but it's far too late in my opinion. Anyway.
Now let me ask you this, though. We talked about it a little bit yesterday, but it seems to me like Trump thinks that he's going to show up in a meeting and have this ace in his back pocket to pull out when he needs. But I don't think that the folks in China care about Nvidia chips anymore.
I think that they're moving on. No, they do. First- They do care about Nvidia chips, for sure.
Of course they do. Yeah. Let's be clear here.
We spoke about this yesterday. I did a 30-page special report on this topic. Good.
Of, we won't sell them to you, we'll rent them to you. And what's really dirty about it is we actually know which data centers in Asia, what chips, and what Chinese companies are using those chips. We know Tencent is using this Malaysian data center.
Baidu is using this one in Singapore, this one in the Philippines. We know all this, and we wink, wink, and turn the other way because, well, some say because Howard Lutnick and his sons who run Cantor Fitzgerald are financially- Mm-hmm ... It's all in my report.
I laid it all out there. Mm-hmm. But here's the, not idiocy, but the hypocrisy of the whole thing.
Donald Trump says, "Well, we knew this, but we can't say anything. What do you want to do, offend Mr. " Right?
We don't want to offend the Chinese Premier or whatever he is, Politburo boss or what, I don't know, what, he's president? President. Right?
" Yeah. He's not going to do anything. He's not going to confront anything.
He's not going to say anything. He's not even going to bring it up. Can I actually- Hold on, I got one more point, John.
Then come back to you ... I have actually something that's even creepier. But- Yeah, but so he's not going to bring it up.
Ooh, that's creepy. But then secondly, as part of his tough talk, they talk about this Pax Silica. He's going to unite the rest of the world on US AI and US technology.
And we've got the Middle East, and we're going to do these Asian countries, and it's Pax Silica. Like Pax Silicone. And this San Francisco agreement that John's talking about that has a very sort of communist euphemistic- ...
title, Happy Seasons, and all of this stuff, it's all part of this Pax Silica. But the rest of the world's not so keen on it because they see Trump and the US talking tough over here, and being really soft over here. Okay.
So I'm going to be really brief, then I'm going to stop talking. Go ahead. I'm going to be brief, and I'll stop talking and let everyone else chime in.
So as part of this Nvidia news cycle, the latest is the Wall Street Journal exposé. I don't know if you've seen this, but you know who introduced Trump... Or excuse me, Trump.
You know who introduced Jensen Huang to Alice Huang, was Alice Huang's husband- Yes ... who built a data center empire in China? Yes.
So it looks like it was Boris and Natasha reeling in the fish. Yes. It was Jensen Huang.
Come, squirrel. We do good things. Yeah.
I know you like Rocky and Bullwinkle. Yep. I'm surprised you had to mention that.
But they worked as a team. To kind of expose and take advantage of this guy. This is such an embarrassment.
I'm sorry. I'm going to stop No, what would be embarrassing is if the NVIDIA board invites Jensen back. They're not.
They've leaked that they have no interest in bringing him back, but maybe they're under pressure from the shareholders. We'll see how earnings go today. Yeah, that's a big thing.
Earnings are today. Earnings are a lagging indicator, so they're not really indicative. It's not so much what the earnings are, but how it's presented.
What they say during the-- Right. Right? Because Jensen would go on there, and it was always, as great as the earnings were, how great they were going to be.
Right? Jensen, at the end of the day, is one of the greatest salesmen of our generation. Yeah.
I agree. Yeah. And let's see how the CFO does it.
You mean he's not just some humble engineer from Denny's? What are you talking about? No, he eats at Denny's.
He doesn't work at Denny's. He begins in Oregon State, where he met his wife. Yes.
It all came out. I read a story that said that Denny's has taken the plaque down at his entry. No, they put it back up.
They put it back up. Did they? All right.
But guys, this really is not about Jensen. It's not about Jensen. This is about, as a country- Correct ...
are we serious about denying China access to these chips? Because Mike, in spite of what you say, China does not have anything close to the Blackwells or the ones coming after Blackwell. Right?
They want access to these chips. And when we see the Chinese models making such progress, it's not because they're training them on abacuses. It's because- I don't know ...
they're training them on our chips. I got $20 that says pillow talk has resulted in them making quite an advance in the amount of capabilities they have. Well, that is true.
I think that is totally true, yes. They're becoming less dependent, perhaps, China. Mm-hmm.
So they got a nice head start thanks to the man of the leather jackets. And just to put a finer point on that, so if there is espionage involved, what do you think the odds are that somebody in the Chinese apparatus has video of Jensen in some way? Oh, maybe.
Oh, yes. No doubt. And how many of those conversations were recorded?
Because I'm wondering- Remember when the report first came out, there were all these denials about this Alice Wong. Then you saw photos everywhere, almost every documented- Yeah ... meeting, right, Kate?
Right. You want to know the truth? I don't think Jensen gave her trade secrets to building the next GPUs.
I think- I think she went into- ... she used Jensen to get mega speed, $5 billion in chips. I think she got his passcode and dived into his laptop.
She didn't need to ask. It was right there. That's so good.
But what I found interesting, back to Alan's point, is the folks present on the planes going. You had Rubio, but you had Bessent, you had Lutnick. And I was thinking to myself, it's surprising it wasn't like one of these fights in the MMA.
Well, I was going to say, if Dana White was there, they might've had a UFC fight, right? Yeah. I bet.
Tell true. Little Marco- There's going to be a revengeant trip to Lake Tahoe now ... and Scottie Bessent against Howard Lutnick.
Lutnick, yeah. So, what are the odds that we wind up with this end of this trip, an announcement that says, "We're declaring victory. " Yeah.
100%. Yeah. Yeah, we get zero.
I get so tired of the tough talk, and it's exhausting. And isn't anybody surprised at the... I mean, for lack of a-- Capitalism is out the door, and socialism from the Republican Party.
If Reagan could be here right now. This is incredible. How many companies?
It's just so shocking. I can't even believe. What I thought about at the end of these negotiations is that basically, the person who's going to be hosed here is Ukraine after this discussion, and Kim maybe coming over.
" What the heck? Why not just invite Kim Jong Un? Yeah.
It's just nuts. Isn't anybody surprised? Oh, no.
It doesn't surprise me. Nothing surprises anybody at this point. I just fear Putin and Xi- Yeah ...
in the room with our president- Yeah. They'll probably- ... and what could come out of that.
They're probably going to call Kim. They probably will give him a call. No, he's calling Kim.
He said he wants to meet Kim, too. He misses him. Well, he'll probably be part of the Zoom call, and good luck if we do, too.
Can you imagine? My God. You think the Ukrainians are afraid?
What about the Taiwanese? They're sitting right there on the other side. Yeah.
I'll tell you who is there, and I bet you comes out of it smelling like a rose with a couple of good trade deals, is Mark Carney. Yeah. You're right.
Because he's the adult in the room. Yeah, that is true. All right.
So- Good thing you mentioned that ... so what is your sense as this all plays out, though? Does the president really even have the authority to make any kind of deal given the last midterm elections?
Because whatever he comes back with is not going to be greeted with the same level of enthusiasm it once was. I don't think he cares, actually. And it's just like the golf course, right?
He does whatever he wants, and the ballroom and everything. I feel like there is no stopping him. Look at who the Republicans have appointed.
I'm not trying to come down on the Republicans, and I'm not- No, but Kate, the Republicans in Congress, I think, are starting to revolt a little bit in the Senate. But Jim Jordan, look at what's happening. Well, that.
Yeah. I said the Senate. Yeah.
You said the Senate. But I think the Senate's kind of wise to him. But there are more than a handful of Republicans that are not pro-China, that's for sure.
Yes. Yeah. This is true.
And Rubio. I don't think Trump gets a deal out of this, right? Because I'm sure there will be books written for hundreds of years about the insanity of the last 10 years.
But the fact of the matter is, Donald Trump tries to go get a deal that would be the deal of deals, that no one else would get a deal like this, because it's the art of the deal. And then he comes back with little to nothing. Yeah.
And you can look at every deal he's been involved in, and that kind of sums it up. Perhaps the only deal that really stuck was the Abraham Accords in the Middle East, and quite frankly, that was probably done by Kushner- Yeah ... and those guys.
So, I don't think you're going to have a deal here. I think Putin's going to be spitting nickels because they blew up his bridge. Yeah.
Right? So that's going to be top of mind to him. Yeah.
Trump is kind of hemmed in here on what he could do with these chips because they're not going to let him sell these chips to China, and Bessent and Rubio and the rest of the hawks on the administration are going to clamp down on the rented chip stuff. Yeah. We can hope.
But can I just say, go download my report. It has it all in there. Yes.
You don't even need to register for it. com. There's an article I wrote, and it has the link to the report in it.
If you're really into all this stuff, it's all in there. Well. That's great.
I don't think he's going to get rid of the fee for renting. He's just going to give it to him. It'll be all right.
You don't insult a man like President Xi. Yeah. Anyway, let's continue on to a different flavor of crazy.
Okay. So, we have a series of outages continuing. You mentioned the one that was reported today involving the national security apparatus.
The banks have had an issue, United Airlines had an issue, Workday had an issue. It just seems the hits keep on coming here. This, of course, is engendering all kinds of conspiracy theories.
I shared a video with Alan where the folks from Anonymous are claiming that this is all part of a conspiracy to convince us to sign up for more centralized government services and totalitarian regimes, because we're all going to be attacked by some foreign country in the Middle East. And then I saw somebody else put out something that was equally amusing. They were saying that, well, the government has a Genesis project that they are putting together around AI, and this Genesis project is the thing that's breaking everything else that's out there.
And none of this is reported, and that's just two. I think there's hundreds of these theories out there, but it's all very entertaining. But Chris, is this just happenstance and coincidenky, or is there something more at work here do you think?
So, I posted an article yesterday, as it's almost impossible to stop me from doing for God knows what reason. But on LinkedIn, this one's really seemed to strike a chord. It's the copper wire was never the problem.
I mean, comparing the FAA with what we spent the last 15 minutes talking about, the dependency on. We have built systems architecturally. I didn't add anything to the last blog because you folks had it covered and I'm just repeating myself.
But we have built systems over and over again, and it's one of the characteristic failure states we're going through right now. And just those two things last week. So we've had financial and geopolitical dependencies on an individual, a single person, Jensen Huang.
He happens to be the CEO of this company that as John and Alan, you guys have talked over the weeks in this show, the financing. It's like, okay, Jensen says, "I will loan money to the people who are buying things from us," and that justifies the stock of the- Mm-hmm. And so the event happened the way it did.
But if it was a car crash, did anybody have a plan for if the CEO of Nvidia or these other half dozen pivotal things that the entire global economy pivots around, what if they just go away or start acting totally different? Are we really serious we're going to build a global infrastructure the scale that we have now, which is unprecedented in not just all of human history, our lives. There's this interconnected system that we're now adding AI to.
And the FAA thing. As an old-timer infrastructure person, I love this one because we don't know exactly, but it is obviously a single point of failure. And whatever layer or combination of decisions brought us there, it's the same result.
So, are we really going to continue to build systems that, big chunks of the last segment, where AI security for national supply chains and so forth is contingent on this Pact Silica sort of thing, which we all know is unenforceable, but the number of things talked about in the last segment. So we put these rules in place and can actors with plenty of incentives hack around them? Oh, yeah.
I'll just rent the GPUs on somebody else's country, and there's no way to detect. So whether it's software bill of materials and software supply chain security, we don't have the structural, defensible reasons to feel comfortable having dependencies that are so few and so brittle. And it's just popping up everywhere.
All right. Well, Kate, let me ask you, because you've been around this for a long time, but we were supposed to have no single points of failure. This is fundamental computer architecture.
And yet, every time we turn around, we have single points of failure. Yeah, big surprise. For me, I don't think it's a cybersecurity attack.
I think forever, especially if you look at critical infrastructure, we are still on analog, baby. And analog, analog, and digital, I mean, hey, I've dealt with those 66 blocks and we still have 66 blocks out there. And you want to add in this...
We're at the point where our system is actually breaking. And I don't know when it is that we-- And you can't throw enough money to solve this problem. It's not a money problem.
It is a design problem. Mm-hmm. And if we don't start to actually understand what do we need to make our digital network and everything that it encompasses to actually be what it should be today, we're going to keep having these incidences.
We don't even need to have hackers. Hackers can go on vacation. Because don't worry, this is just- It'll fall over on its own ...
it's just going to keep going. We've added too much, and it is so time that we actually, for real, say, "Okay, how do we do this? " Alan, it's so much similar to your book.
It's how do we make infrastructure so that it can go into the next century? Because right now, it's collapsing before our eyes. And I'll be honest, it's not just our digital infrastructure.
No, it's not. Our roads, our bridges- It doesn't ... our electric grid.
Yeah. It's across the board. So let me give you a peek inside the mind of Alan Shimel.
So I look at what's been going on this last week or two, and my first decision tree is: Is this hacking? Is there someone doing these things to us, or is it just old, decrepit stuff? Some of it might, in fact, be hacking.
Certainly, the French refrigeration- Yeah ... units were hacked. Yeah.
Then when I look at okay, that's hacking. This wasn't hacking. Is it government infrastructure or is it private?
Because there's an expectation in our country that the government can't do s**t right. Yeah. Let's face it.
Yeah. It's inefficient. It winds up costing 10 times the amount.
But what's interesting is when we were young, yes, the government was more expensive to do things then, but the government built stuff you can count on. Yeah. Right?
I mean, when you looked at when the Army built something or NASA built something, it may be really expensive, but it was fault tolerant. It worked. Yeah.
Well, Kate, you're exactly right. It worked like that. These are design issues.
And it costs a little more in theory, or you've got to make different choices as you're designing resilient systems. But if you don't, the cost in the end, it should be a cliché, the cost in the end will be much higher. And as we look at the entire systems, the technical systems, economic systems, political systems, and you see the reward for the wrong behavior.
I can start a company up and spend less money and make a lot of money and put that company out of business and walk away fine. Yeah. Now, somebody else is going to pay the price for the choices I made.
Yeah, but Chris, when you're talking about JPMorgan Chase Bank or Wells Fargo, these aren't fly-by-nights that someone built to sold and walk away from. These are probably some of the most, supposedly, most robust, resilient systems in the world. Am I right?
Yes and no. And here's the no part of it. " Sounds like a big number.
And then you get into those numbers, and you discover that 98% of that money is going into supporting legacy systems and personnel and staffing, and only 2%, if you're lucky, goes to anything related to innovation. So maybe we need to just pony up a little bit here and say one of two things. Either we're going to go in and fix these systems and reallocate those dollars to do that, or B, we need to spend more on IT to shore up the existing stuff while we build some new stuff alongside it.
But to me, all this is coming home to roost, and it's been an issue that's been kicking around for decades. So I was talking with our colleague, Mitch, and he made a really good point. He said that he thinks And I think it's kind of building on what Mike just said.
The larger risk is that banks, airlines, other critical services run on a small number of shared cloud network and software providers. And enterprises buy those dependencies one contract at a time and really map up what they add up to. Fair enough.
And this is the consequence of that. So let me- Sure. I got to counter to that, though.
Okay. So Mitch and I started a company called Still Secure. The best engineer we had there, hands down, the best engineer I ever met was a guy named Dave Greenstein.
" Yeah. Right? OT, they're simpler by design, but a lot more redundant and a lot more fault tolerant.
And we've designed them as IT networks, not OT networks. " So maybe it is something... Chris is smiling.
Maybe it is something about all this AI and all these upgrades that we're doing that is breaking what... " Maybe there's something to that. That's what Dave Greenstein says.
Oh. With that type of thought process, what about the bridges that... Do we not fix bridges that are cracking?
Yeah. They're still working. I think we need to design for today.
Gosh, I used to quote, when I was with IBM, that it was like a 80/20. So Mike, you talked about what 2% of the budget. We used to talk about there being like 80%, where 20% was new technology doing something new.
I much agree more so with your stats and not these. Of course, they're a lot older. " I think we're like that with business.
This idea that there is something to keeping the lights on, but we really need to get some, not just cybersecurity architects, but real architects that can look at the system and decide and understand how do we put old and new together. You know the scene that I love with Tom Hanks and Apollo 13, right? 13.
Where you get a bunch of engineers in the room, and it was Ed Harris, right? He comes and he just dumps everything that they have on the table of what the astronauts have. " We almost have that situation.
" It's the exact same thing. All right. But yeah, I'll- How many of you think this is also related to the fact that, and we've reported this in the past, where companies are now spending more of the IT budget on AI and cutting back the number of people they have in their IT department to help fund that, and maybe some of that too is at play here because the people who kept these systems running- Oh, you think the 60,000 people that got laid off maybe had anything to do with Microsoft?
But I was joking to myself and my husband this morning. You know what no one was saying during all these outages? " But anyway, sorry.
I just always think it's so- Good digress. No one was saying that. Neil the Seal, I don't know if you guys are familiar with the lovable seal in Australia, or maybe it's New Zealand, that goes and wreaks havoc on this local town.
They published, or someone published, the recovery management plan. Neil the Seal, literally this adorable figure on the internet that everyone can relate to who just wreaks havoc on a town once a year. They have a fully baked recovery plan.
Now, do you think that any of these entities involved have a comprehensive, to Kate's point, do you think they've all sat in a room and said, "Let's really work out what these future problems could be," and what are those recovery plans? That's sort of where I was left. Hey, let's give Chris a chance here.
Come on. Yeah, because this block is all about resilience and fragility and so forth, and as you just said, Anne, and your friend Dave Allen, OT has this down. And to be clear, OT isn't lower tech, right?
There's wonderful, fantastic high tech stuff going on in water systems and oil rigs and so forth, but it's more mature. You think about safety. There's security and there's safety.
Safety is a different bloody thing. You think through everything. What if all the people change?
How does the funding work? How does the politics work over 40 years? You actually think about it because it matters, and we have skimmed over the top with IT all of our lives and all my career, and it's been fun, but no, that is not reliable stuff.
And if you scroll back, and for the viewers out there, go back before April of last year and you'll see me on the same show on a pair of ridiculous solar powered boats. Alan, you were on board the Twaynes. And through five hurricanes and 5,000 miles and three years, I sailed the bloody things up and down.
I was never even offline, right? This can be done. OT people know this stuff backwards.
We need to pay the price. It comes at a price, right? We can't have all our dependencies on the fact that we saved 5% over the last 30 years by not making a redundant FAA network, or we can't afford to be entirely dependent on a single CEO staying at one of five companies or the economy crashes, right?
Oh, yeah. We know how to build this stuff. We just need to do it.
It's not a technical debt at that point, it's a technical deficit. Yeah. Well, I'm getting ready for AWS re:Invent, and I figured I would rent a 1970s Mustang completely analog and make it drive.
You need to write- Hey, maybe we could feature that as a reality show on Techshow TV. But Mike, we're way over. We need to jump to our third- All right.
Jumping to the third one. So, the FBI, citing some work that Google has done, and some other folks, has confirmed that, by golly, those vicious, crazy, bad folks are using AI to attack us. I know we were all shocked to hear that, but Kate, I got a feeling this might be just the tip of the iceberg with these reports.
Is this going to be just wave after wave of this stuff? For that, I'm going to say absolutely 100% yes. And you led into it in the previous when talking about AI leading the way and getting rid of people.
It doesn't surprise me, right? So what was it? Under three hours, AI found privilege escalation.
Basically privilege, admin privileges. And whenever I was talking from a cybersecurity workshop and things, the top three things that customers would ask me is not only lateral movement, I'm sure, and command and control. That makes perfect sense, right?
Chris, especially with OT, right? Command and control there. But the third was privilege escalation.
So is it a surprise? Our techs is going to continue to find it faster than an alert can even get on a SOC board. Before we, as humans, can even investigate what the heck is happening, the whole entire enterprise has been mapped out with all the different vulnerabilities.
It's only going to become more so. Yeah. " So- When I was at IBM, Watson was everything 10 years ago.
And we would talk about the point that Watson was going to replace junior analysts, get rid of the false positives. And what I don't understand is it seems like we're able to use AI for these, like pointing out all the things that we have done poorly, like, with some of these application stuff that we've done, and because it takes advantages of human weaknesses. But why doesn't AI...
It doesn't seem to do really the opposite for us. It doesn't seem to find, like, okay, hey, this is a whole... Maybe we can do something with that.
It just exposes everything. Why can't we do the opposite? Right.
But whose fault is that? Who's driving the car? We are.
The clowns. It's a clown car. Honestly, clown car sounds fun.
But what really sticks out about me about the story is the time, three hours. And as soon as I saw that, that felt exactly right. And it's important.
This is not three days. It's not three seconds. It's not three seconds.
It's not magic. There's no beating the second law of thermodynamics in here. Things take time.
And it's not three days. Like in three days, if you're really good and you've got the right resources, maybe you can do it in three days. Now it's three hours.
And that matters because you need to adjust around that. It's an indicator of where we are. And that'll reduce.
Again, it won't go to three seconds, not for the same work. It'll go from three hours to maybe 90 minutes to an hour. So design around that.
I keep hearing from folks that we're focused on the wrong thing. Yeah. There'll always be too big a gap for actually patching something.
And so the name of the game then becomes how do you apply the mitigating controls in near real time when these attacks get detected to buy time for the patches? And it seems like everybody's talking about we need to patch faster when maybe we just need to apply controls faster. Kate?
We will not be able, Alan, as I said at Checkfield Day, we cannot patch our way out of this. We need to almost eliminate that from our heads. Don't even follow that path.
We're not going to be able to patch our way out of this. It's not realistic. It would be good to understand, Chris, you said three hours, an hour, and I agree.
You can only go as fast as things can go, as fast as the networks and everything else can go. But we're going to have to do mitigating controls, I think, at the end. And really, people, gosh, let me just call back in these engineers and architects.
We've got to start doing things differently. We have to really rethink the way that we are building our infrastructure as we're going forward to understand how reachability, software bloating. We've got to start addressing these issues.
We have a lot of bad stuff. We can't just keep hiding things under the rug. Pretty soon, the rug is all full of junk, and we're tripping over the rug.
We can't keep sweeping things underneath the rug, folks. It just doesn't- Sorry, Kate. I just like this confluence of things that are contradictory.
We have this aging infrastructure. We've got these restructuring pushed by these companies to bring in AI at the expense of humans. " Sorry.
That's comforting. So what you're describing is a very elaborate game of Jenga, right? We talked about that.
V is the Jenga model. They're the pieces that are falling out. And by the way, Anthropic is going public on Wednesday.
I wonder how all this is going to impact that. Wednesday is Wednesday. Yeah.
I think it gets priced Wednesday, right? Priced Wednesday night, Thursdays. You're right.
So look, my question is this: Do I need the frigging FBI to tell me that hackers are using AI platforms? Doesn't Kash Patel have something better to do? Like do whatever it is he does?
Go to his girlfriend's concert or whatever. Yeah. And all of that stuff on flyer prizes- Fly around on a taxpayer bill.
You want to talk about the Captain Obvious Award? That's what we're spending money on? To tell me that attackers are using AI?
Stop. Well, hey, again, of all the stories that flow by, again, I like this one. It's a quantification of the timeframe because in a world where- So I think the timeframes are off, Chris.
I don't think it's three hours. I think it's negative time. By the time we find out about a zero day, the bad guys have known about it for a couple of days.
My point being that if that is reality, and it is, you need to design around that. And Kate, to your point, the CVE system, the idea that we're going to patch everything, that's not a thing. And I want to give a shout-out to the friend of the show, Fred Cohen, in 1993, I think, wrote a great paper on this, and I think that's where we are right now.
You need not to have the single code base, the single system installed on the entire bloody world so the whole thing falls over. And I think that's where we are right now. You look at drift.
Look at the word drift in the context of AI, AI governance in the working groups. Systems drift around a lot. And we've been trying very hard to make that not happen because that's the only way we can manage things by having the same software on 100 million machines.
Once that starts to happen, you're more likely to survive the three-hour or three-second attack because you're not exactly like everybody else. But there's also- My point being that if things aren't going to happen, stop building for those and try to find what is at least possible. But Chris, there are advantages to standardization, right?
There is an advantage to the Linuxes or Unixes, or there used to be Unixes. But here's the point behind that all, though, is we've got to do the remediation paths that we take with the CVEs and the patching are just never going to AI scale. We've got to talk about containment.
We've got to talk about containing blast radiuses. We've got to talk about mitigation. Right?
Mm-hmm. These are all well-founded sort of risk principles that we need to start applying, because I don't care whether everyone has a bespoke platform or not. With AI, AI doesn't care either.
You just point it in the direction, and it'll find it. Right? " Right.
Can I add something to that mix? Because I- You got it, Mike. Last word ...
I do think about this, and this will be an insight into maybe the way my mind works. But every Wednesday, I fire up my machine, it reboots after patch Tuesday, and I always wonder how long will it be before my machine keels over because the patches are getting bigger and bigger for every cycle. And by the way, then I can't afford to buy a new machine because, well, AI sucked up all the memory for it, so now I'm kind of screwed.
Amen to that. I just went to upgrade a machine and $500 extra for the hard... It's solid state hard drive, so it's a memory chip.
But 500 bucks extra for the same amount of hard drive space that I had in my old machine from five years ago. I went back and looked at it. Mm-hmm.
The price of an Apple SSD terabyte hard drive in my M1 iMac versus the price of this new M6 iMac with the same terabyte hard drive. Mm-hmm. So- More than double the price for the hard drive.
See? So patching's become cost prohibitive. Think about it.
Yeah. That's one way of looking at it. Hey, we're about out of time, though.
Anne, it's so great seeing you out here. Come back soon. Yes?
Will do. All right. How many TV shows you up to these days?
106. 106. There we go.
Kate, Chris, I assume we'll see you next Tuesday on The Duo. Yes. Yep.
And John and Mike, as always, great job. Thank you for watching. We do do this show every Monday to Friday at noon, and it's live on the Techstrong Network.
tv, the Techstrong TV YouTube channel, or the newly redesigned, thanks to Taylor, our engineer here, on Techstrong OTT app. Check it out. But until tomorrow, on behalf of the gang, have a great day, everyone.
Stay safe out there.